External risk intelligence

OpenSSH Smartcard Key Management Risk

CVE advisorySeverity: CRITICAL (CVSS 9.8)

CVE-2023-28531

A flaw in OpenSSH's `ssh-add` feature allows smartcard keys to be added to the `ssh-agent` without intended restrictions. This could enable unauthorized access to data and systems, posing a business risk. Organizations using affected versions should identify and secure these systems.

1Halo Surface Signal

Openbsd Openssh

8.9 to before 9.3

External exposure likelihood

Halo Surface Signal score for CVE-2023-28531

This vulnerability affects ssh-add, a client-side utility used to manage smartcard keys within an ssh-agent. It is a local, developer-centric command-line tool executed by users on their own systems to interact with local or forwarded agents. It is not a network service, daemon, or gateway, and it lacks any exposure to the public internet in standard deployment patterns.

Horizon Alert

Summary of the vulnerability and why it matters

The `ssh-add` feature in OpenSSH versions 8.9 up to, but not including, 9.3 contains a flaw related to how smartcard keys are managed. This weakness allows smartcard keys to be added to the `ssh-agent` without the intended restrictions on their destination. This could create business risks if sensitive data or systems are accessed inappropriately.

  • Vulnerable component: `ssh-add` feature
  • Core weakness: Keys added without destination constraints
  • Main business impact: Unauthorized access to data/systems

Attack Path

How an attacker could exploit the issue

This vulnerability impacts organizations that use specific versions of OpenSSH. The attack allows an unauthenticated attacker to gain unauthorized access to sensitive data. The attacker can then execute arbitrary code or commands on the affected system. This could lead to a significant compromise of the organization's systems and data.

  • Exposed via network access.
  • Attacker gains system access.
  • Commands executed, data compromised.

Live Threat

Current exploitation, exposure, and threat context

This vulnerability could allow attackers to bypass security controls by adding smartcard keys to an SSH agent without proper destination constraints. The impact can include unauthorized access to systems and data, potentially leading to significant business disruption. Organizations should assess their use of the affected software and prioritize mitigation efforts.

  • Attackers likely need low skill.
  • Requires local access or specific conditions.
  • High business risk or urgency.

Priority actions

Operational Fix

Recommended remediation, mitigation, and detection steps

This vulnerability in OpenSSH could allow attackers to add unauthorized smartcard keys to the ssh-agent, potentially leading to elevated access. Organizations should identify all systems using the affected OpenSSH versions. Reducing exposure involves isolating these systems or implementing additional security controls. Applying the vendor fix, verifying its successful implementation, and monitoring for unusual activity are the final steps.

  • Find affected OpenSSH assets.
  • Limit access to vulnerable systems.
  • Apply vendor fix and verify.

Frequently asked questions

What is OpenSSH and its ssh-add command?

OpenSSH is a suite of secure networking tools for remote login, file transfer, and other network services. The `ssh-add` command specifically manages user identity keys for smartcards and loads them into `ssh-agent` for authentication.

What is the weakness in CVE-2023-28531 for OpenSSH?

CVE-2023-28531 describes a CWE-284 weakness where `ssh-add` in OpenSSH versions 8.9 through 9.2 adds smartcard keys to `ssh-agent` without enforcing intended destination restrictions, potentially allowing unintended key usage.

How does CVE-2023-28531 impact systems?

This vulnerability allows attackers to bypass security controls by adding smartcard keys to an SSH agent without proper destination constraints. This could lead to unauthorized system and data access, potentially causing significant business disruption.

What is the relevance of CVE-2023-28531 according to Halo Surface Signal?

Halo Surface Signal assesses CVE-2023-28531 as 'Very unlikely' to be exploited externally, as `ssh-add` is a client-side utility for managing keys on user systems, not a network service exposed to the internet.

What are the practical steps to address CVE-2023-28531?

Organizations should identify systems using affected OpenSSH versions, limit access to vulnerable systems, apply the vendor fix, verify its implementation, and monitor for unusual activity.

References