External risk intelligence

OpenSSL SSL_select_next_proto Buffer Overread via Empty Protocol List

CVE advisorySeverity: CRITICAL (CVSS 9.1)

CVE-2024-5535

The vulnerability exists in a specific OpenSSL API function, SSL_select_next_proto, which is only reachable if an application explicitly implements it incorrectly with a zero-length list of supported protocols. This is a developer-level programming error rather than a common deployment configuration, making it unlikely to be broadly exploitable across typical public-facing services despite the underlying library usage.

Out-of-bounds Read

Halo Surface Signal: 2 out of 5 — less likely to be public-facing.

External exposure likelihood

Horizon Alert

Summary of the vulnerability and why it matters

A recent issue has been identified in the OpenSSL cryptographic library that could lead to unexpected application behavior or a crash. In specific, non-standard configurations where a particular API function is called incorrectly, it could potentially expose up to 255 bytes of private memory data to a network peer, impacting data confidentiality. The main concern is confirming if any applications within our environment directly utilize this function in a vulnerable manner.

  • A rare coding error could leak memory data.
  • Consider this if direct API misuse occurs.
  • Confirm relevance; the risk appears low.

Attack Path

How an attacker could exploit the issue

An attacker could potentially trigger a crash or leak private memory by sending a specially crafted network request to an application that incorrectly uses a specific OpenSSL function. This function, when called with an empty list of supported protocols, fails to handle the error properly, leading to the disclosure of up to 255 bytes of arbitrary data from the application's memory. The vulnerability is not typically under direct attacker control, but may arise from programming or configuration errors.

  • Requires specific programming error.
  • Triggers with empty protocol list.
  • Leaks memory, causes denial of service.

Live Threat

Current exploitation, exposure, and threat context

When an application incorrectly calls a specific OpenSSL function with an empty list of supported protocols, it could expose up to 255 bytes of arbitrary private data from memory to a connected peer. This scenario is only possible in applications that directly use the `SSL_select_next_proto` API and is typically due to a programming or configuration error rather than an attacker-controlled action.

  • Potential memory data exposure.
  • Incorrect API call by application.
  • Loss of confidentiality.

Operational Fix

Recommended remediation, mitigation, and detection steps

Action for this vulnerability likely falls to application owners who directly use the affected OpenSSL API function, in coordination with platform or infrastructure teams managing the underlying systems. The immediate practical step is to identify applications that call `SSL_select_next_proto` with a zero-length client protocol list. Confirming if these instances are active, business-critical, and reachable externally will inform risk-based remediation planning.

  • Application owners should verify API usage.
  • Confirm reachability and business criticality.
  • Plan targeted updates or configuration changes.

Supplementary metadata

Validate whether this threat affects your internet-facing exposure.

Halo Threat Intelligence helps prioritize remediation with Halo Surface Signal and H/A/L/O context. Start exposure validation with a free external attack surface trial.

Frequently asked questions

What is the role of OpenSSL and SSL_select_next_proto?

OpenSSL provides cryptographic tools for secure network communication. The SSL_select_next_proto function is an API used during TLS handshakes to negotiate supported application-level protocols. It helps servers and clients select a mutually compatible protocol version, ensuring that the secure connection is established using a standard and efficient data exchange method.

What is CVE-2024-5535 and its associated weakness?

CVE-2024-5535 is an out-of-bounds read vulnerability, identified as CWE-125, within the OpenSSL library. It occurs when the SSL_select_next_proto function is invoked with an empty list of supported client protocols. This oversight prevents the function from properly validating input lengths, potentially allowing the software to read memory beyond intended buffer boundaries.

How is this memory overread vulnerability triggered?

The vulnerability is triggered only when an application incorrectly calls SSL_select_next_proto with a zero-length protocol list. It does not stem from standard network traffic. If the list is empty, the function fails to detect the condition and returns memory content immediately following the buffer pointer, which may then be sent to the peer, causing a crash or information leak.

Why is this issue considered unlikely to be exploited?

According to the Halo Surface Signal, this vulnerability is unlikely to be exploited because it requires a specific, incorrect developer implementation rather than a common configuration. Since it relies on a programming error in the calling application rather than an inherent library flaw accessible via standard usage, the risk to typical services remains low.

How should organizations address this vulnerability?

Application owners must identify code paths that invoke SSL_select_next_proto and verify if they pass a zero-length protocol list. Teams should assess whether these specific implementations are reachable by external traffic and prioritize updates to ensure robust input validation. Remediation focuses on correcting the application-level logic to prevent improper API usage.

References